Negative Articles against Cuccinelli Not a Smear Campaign

Lorraine Yuriar of the Hampton Roads Tea Party posted, on the Suffolk Democratic Committee’s Facebook page, a link to her HRTP article about a smear campaign against Ken Cuccinelli. Her article was prompted by a Virginian Pilot article concerning possibly misleading information that Cuccinelli provided about his service in the United States Marines.

But while she gives the journalist a pass for digging up dirt, she uses search results from the Pilot’s website, hamptonroads.com, to theorize that the Pilot is biased against Ken Cuccinelli.

… in total, of the 8 stories on the first page of search results for Terry McAuliffe, half of the articles are favorable to Terry, and only 2 of the articles were old.

On the other hand a quick search for Ken Cuccinelli turns up 8 articles, but all of them are old! The latest article on the first page of the search is dated November 2012.

I found that very strange considering Ken Cuccinelli’s involvement in the Star Scientific affair. I figured the Pilot must have written about Ken Cuccinelli more recently than November.

It has. Unfortunately, HamptonRoads.com has a lousy search engine.

Although the first page of search results for McAuliffe does have more recent articles then the first page of search results about Cuccinelli, if you add the second page you’ll see that Cuccinelli brings up more recent results. I found that the first two pages of results on “Cuccinelli” contain nine articles in July, while the first two pages of results for “McAuliffe” contain only three for July.

Ms. Yuriar is right about the overall count of negative articles about Cuccinelli vs the count of negative articles about McAulliffe, but that is due to Cuccinelli’s involvement in Star Scientific.

Cuccinelli has been investigated for owning stock in Star Scientific and accepting gifts from Star Scientific executive Jonnie Williams, while defending the State of Virginia against a lawsuit filed by that company. News about Ken Cuccinelli’s involvement in Star Scientific is part of a larger scandal surrounding the company’s relationship with Virginia’s governor, Bob McDonnell.

As it turns out, news broke yesterday that Ken Cuccinelli has been cleared of ethics violations in that scandal. Not because he’s squeaky clean though. It still holds true that he only recused himself from the case after Cuccinelli’s relationship with Star Scientific became public. And he still broke the law by not reporting those gifts and his stock in a timely manner. So even if at the end of an investigation into whether or not Cuccinelli’s relationship with Star Scientific violated Virginia’s weak ethics laws, Cuccinelli’s relationship with Star Scientific was, and still is, news.

The Pilot has no obligation to ignore Cuccinelli’s inappropriate (even if not illegal) behavior just to look fair and balanced.

Update (same day as posting) I changed the title from: Negative Articles against Cuccinelli Not Necessarily a Smear Campaign.

Advertisements
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s